ABC News's "Prescription for America": Informative or Infomercial?
As my colleague Jeff Bailey noted in an earlier post here, we were expecting some people to exercise their constitutional rights tonight and protest airing of the ABC News special "Prescription for America" that was broadcast from 10 to 11pm (and continued on a special edition of Nightline at 11:35pm) on News Channel 8. (We were expecting them because they emailed us to announce their event.)
In fact, about two dozen people did show up outside our Elm street studios in New Haven tonight holding signs, chanting slogans and being cheered on by the occasional honking of passing cars.
I went out and spoke to the people gathered at about 9pm, first to tell them that we would be shooting some video of them exercising their free speech for our late newscast and then to ask why they were protesting a program that hadn't been broadcast yet?
Their answers were similar in tone, a few people quoted the "talking point" that they had read or heard that there wouldn't be anyone in the ABC audience that wasn't hand picked by ABC, and there would be no opposition voices to President Obama. There were others who told me that they just oppose any kind of government run health care plan--even though they admit there hasn't been a plan actually drafted yet, so far there are just conversations about what each side thinks should or should not be in a final plan. A couple of people expressed their opinions about the legitimacy of Mr. Obama being the President, reciting the theories held by some that he hasn't been "proven" to be a US Citizen.
Let me say that every opinion didn't appear to be shared by everyone present, and even though I asked some sincere questions about what these people saw as media bias that they hadn't even really seen yet, the conversation was lively--but never degraded to the kind of name calling and insulting of obviously sincerely held opinions-- that so often seems to be the mainstay of talk radio programs these days.
I asked everyone to try to take the time to actually watch the ABC News special and decide after doing so, whether or not their expectations had been realized.
Though I suspect many will see my take as somehow "towing the company line", I watched a good portion of the broadcast tonight, and I was struck by how much ABC anchors Charles Gibson and Diane Sawyer worked at bringing up the objections and concerns about the President's ideas on how best to tackle the issue of providing health care for all Americans. Certainly not every question was answered, or every concern resolved, but I would say that I was satisfied by how ABC worked to present a balanced program, that was by no means a one sided "infomercial" only supporting the President's agenda. At least in my opinion.
So did you watch? What was your take? Whether or not you agree with the President or his opponents on the issue--did ABC News present a balanced program about an issue that impacts every one of us? We'd like to hear your opinions.
27 comments
Basicaly, we have a "over-valued" system that most people CANT afford and they cant afford it by themselves OR with somekind of "insurance".......
If you look back when healthcare insurance was kind of in its "infancy", it was SUPPOSED to cover "catastrophic" illness or accidents that might happen to us, to put "undue" costs onto us....... THAT made sense and if it kept on that path, we would probably not have the problem we have today.......unfortunatly, it eventually covered MOST things, basicly giving the healthcare industry a "green light" to raise costs as they see fit..........basic "free market" principles dont appy anymore, because the costs are "spread out"........somehow in all this "business" gets saddled with responsibility of providing it....today, a HUGE cost for them, part of the reason we are loosing our auto manufacturing in this country...... healthcare is EVERYONES responsibility, not just government our your damn place you work at...........
Then, we have the " anything that is GOOD for you will COST you, whether it needs to or not" mentalty ( f''cking greed ) " yes we have a drug that you can take for HIV......but it cost you $10,000 a month for it".....beautiful............even if that was cut to say, $2000 per month, the damn drug company wont go bankrupt.......
People B-ITCH & whine about the cost of gasoline.......you people ought to be complainin about WHY a 5 mile ambulance ride costs $500.... or that a plastic backbrace that MAYBE costs $75 to make gets charged out at over $2500......a maker of a medical piece of equipment makes a "surcharge" on that from the Dr because THEY have a patent on it...people using emergancy rooms as walk in clinics.......countless "referals" have to be had instead of just going to see the Dr you NEED to go see...the list is ENDLESS...
It doesnt matter if its food, healthcare the enviroment, education....the thought process is the same
If you ask most people about healthcare, there seems to be a mentality out there that it should be FREE..........we DONT live in that kind of world...........sad to say......THESE people need to come back to planet earth...........
Bottom line.........we better find a more "practical" approach on how we "value" things............
PEOPLE MAKE PRICES.................
NOTHING else......................
President Obama didn't have any definitive answers at this point, but I wasn't really expecting any. I have somewhat of a better idea of what he's proposing after last nights broadcast, but really need to acquire a lot more information before I form an opinion.
It's going to be EXTREMELY difficult for Obama to reach the ojectives he's outlined. I can't see how he's going to make it all happen as he envisions health care, but he's certainly going to try. I don't think people in the healtcare profession will be all that cooperative.
my only disagreement is the "need" to tie in Health Insurance Companies/HMOs"... for an effective health care system you only need two things... a patient and a Doctor, that's all...no HMO siphoning off valuable dollars for corporate jets and junkets...(HMOs are obsolete)
i did like the woman who disagreed with the cost... we spend and will continue to spend more money, for less care... other western nations have far better health care and do it for a lot less...we are NOT a world leader in this arena...
They have BCZS- Bush Cult Zombie Syndrome.
And the protesting is a joke, they will not lose their insurance and be forced to go on the govt's, it will be a choice.
A choice the insurance co's do not want you to have.
They are just going to complain about anything Obama does to soothe their assaulted egos about backing GW.
It is so strange how these people think, like being repubs is a special club and you cannot let it go.
Let it go people, they ruined this country from 2000-2008, gave us 2 wars, and a new depression.
Look at our infrastructure, the train crash the other day, all the money given to Halliburton in NO BID CONTRACTS WASTED...
...some if it could have been spent here on bridges, subways mass transit, Russias mass transit is incredible and CLEAN
We cannot even count the money spent on Bush Family Oil INC, it is so hard to trace, yet both Cheney and Bush are doing business in Iraq and Iran.
THAT IS OK with the wackos, having health care for all here is not??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
all I can say is...............wow
and if anyone is wondering
What is BCZS and why has it infected GOP, Conservative, Extremist Hardliners?
Well we can post facts all day long, the PDB, the facts about Iraq, facts about Halliburton and Bush family business dealings, facts about GWs past, the clear links between dad and GWs regimes, the destruction of the all govt agencies, our schools, our standing in the world, inaction on abortion, no bid contracts, Iran/Contra, Enron and more.
Those affected with BCZS will refuse to see them
If they do they will be admitting to themselves that they have been wrong in supporting GW and/or the GOP, their inner egos will not allow it, it is a form of self protection, it happens in other cases, usually victims or witnesses of violent crime. They resort to snide comments.
Now not all have this as the election proved, many people have awoke and dropped the GOP like a bad habit, but the hard core groupies carry on, like they have been given keys to the GOP's favorite country clubs, little do they know these people would not give them the time of day.
So that is my theory, after 8 years of posting facts on the crimes of Bush Cheney et al, it seems no amount of truth will cure them, maybe therapy, for now I call it Bush Cult Zombie Syndrome, until medical science can properly name it.
Do you know someone with BCZS????
Call 1-800-BYND HLP Now
How's this for apocalyptic literature. This was written by a pastor's wife in biblical prose as a commentary of current events. It is Brilliant!
~~~~~~~~~
And it came to pass in the Age of Insanity that the people of the land called America , having lost their morals, their initiative, and their will to defend their liberties, chose as their Supreme Leader that person known as "The One".
He emerged from the vapors with a message that had no meaning; but He hypnotized the people telling them, "I am sent to save you. My lack of experience, my questionable ethics, my monstrous ego, and my association with evil doers are of no consequence. For I
shall save you with Hope and Change.
Go, therefore,and proclaim throughout the land that he who preceded me is evil, that he has defiled the nation, and that all he has built must be destroyed." And the people rejoiced, for even though they knew not what "The One" would do, he had promised that it was good; and they believed. And "The One" said "We live in the greatest country in the world. Help me change everything about it!" And the people said, "Hallelujah! Change is good!"
Then He said, "We are going to tax the rich fat-cats." And the people said "Sock it to them!"
"And redistribute their wealth." And the people said, "Show us the money!"
And then He said, "Redistribution of wealth is good for everybody"
And Joe the plumber asked, "Are you kidding me? You're going to steal my money and give it to the deadbeats??"
And "The One" ridiculed and taunted him, and Joe's personal records were hacked and publicized.
One lone reporter asked, "Isn't that Marxist policy?" And she was banished from the kingdom!
Then a citizen asked, "With no foreign relations experience and having zero military experience or knowledge, how will you deal with radical terrorists?" And "The One" said, "Simple. I shall sit with them and talk with them and show them how nice we really are; and
they will forget that they ever wanted to kill us all!" And the people said, "Hallelujah!! We are safe at last, and we can beat our weapons into free cars for the people!"
Then "The One" said, "I shall give 95% of you lower taxes." And one, lone voice said, "But 40% of us don't pay ANY taxes." So "The One" said, "Then I shall give you some of the taxes the fat-cats pay!" And the people said, "Hallelujah!! Show us the money!"
Then "The One" said, "I shall tax your Capital Gains when you sell your homes!" And the people yawned and the slumping housing market collapsed. And He said, "I shall mandate employer- funded health care for EVERY worker and raise the minimum wage. And I shall give every person unlimited healthcare and medicine and transportation to the
clinics." And the people said, "Give me some of that!"
Then he said, "I shall penalize employers who ship jobs overseas." And the people said, "Where's my rebate check?"
Then "The One" said, "I shall bankrupt the coal industry and electricity rates will skyrocket!" And the people said, "Coal is dirty, coal is evil, no more coal! But we don't care for that part about higher electric rates."
So "The One" said, "Not to worry. If
your rebate isn't enough to cover your expenses, we shall bail you out. Just sign up with ACORN and your troubles are over!"
Then He said, "Illegal immigrants feel scorned and slighted. Let's grant them amnesty, Social Security, free education, free lunches, free medical care, bi-lingual signs and guaranteed
housing..."And the people said, "Hallelujah!!" And they made him King!
And so it came to pass that employers, facing spiraling costs and ever-higher taxes, raised their prices and laid off workers. Others simply gave up and went out of business and the economy sank like unto a rock dropped from a cliff. The banking industry was destroyed. Manufacturing slowed to a crawl. And more of the people were without a means of support.
Then "The One" said, "I am the "The One" - The Messiah - and I'm here to save you! We shall just print more money so everyone will have enough!" But our foreign trading partners said unto Him, "Wait a minute. Your dollar is not worth a pile of camel dung! You will have to pay more..." And the people said, "Wait a minute. That is
unfair!!" And the world said, "Neither are these other idiotic
programs you have embraced. Lo, you have become a Socialist state and a second-rate power. Now you shall play by our rules!"
And the people cried out, "Alas, alas!! What have we done?" But
yea verily, it was too late. The people set upon "The One" and spat
upon him and stoned him, and his name was dung. And the once mighty
nation was no more; and the once proud people were without sustenance
or shelter or hope. And the Change "The One" had given them
was as like unto a poison that had destroyed them and like a whirlwind that consumed all that they had built. And the people beat their chests in despair and cried out in anguish, "Give us back our nation and our pride and our hope!!" But it was too late, and their homeland was no more.
Scary, huh?
Obama's rush to create a government run health care program must be stalled- he should be going after the private insurer's and make them drop their exhorbitant cost to be insured. Medicare and Medicaid are government programs and look how disasterous these gov't run programs ended up. HMO's now tell Dr.s what tests they can order and what they cannot - Medicare just flat out refuses to allow many treatments and tests to those on Medicare. As to "choice" that is questionable. I heard him say that if an employee is insured with a company health insurance, they cannot drop the private plan and choose the gov't run plan - so where is the choice here ?
Cost containment means denial of tests, treatments and services - it's done to Medicare patients and if this gov't program gets in, all Americans can expect to be refused specific tests and treatments - that's how Medicare costs are contained. The biggest problem with having a gov't run health plan is that very quietly there will be a different kind of "ethnic cleansing" tasking place - the weak, disabled and chronically ill people can be "erased" by refusing them needed treatment. It's done to the elderly on Medicare - and it is legal to do so under the guise of "cost containment". The insurance companies should be doing the cost containment by dropping the price of insurance - more people could get insurance and insurance companies would make more money. Why no one is pushing that idea is beyond me - is everyone so charmed by Obama's gift of gab ? I'm not - we shall wait and see if common sense reappears in Congress and Obama's plan for his kind of change in health care is shot down. We can hope, can't we ?
you need to get yourself as far away from the right wing wacko brigade as you can, for your own sanity
scary?
what's scary is some people fall for that crap while all the evil horrors committed against the American people from 2000-2008 were the work of God?
we are in a depression Alice due to the greed of the Gw regime, Pennzoil is doing fine in Iran and Iraq as is Halliburton
that should tell you something
and "JOE" the plumber is not a plumber, he was working illegally without a license and owes back taxes
that is the typicle right wing poster child
a fraud liar big mouth that owes taxes and probably cheats on his wife all the while screaming about morals.
what a joke
you will have a choice
stay with insurance co's or go on the govt plan
he is not mandating anything
it is not the end of the world
it is change and we all fear change
mosty the insurance co's fear it and they are paying big bucks to Faux and the GOP to spread fear
why?
why not have an intelligent discussion with just the facts??
instead all you hear is
SOCIALISM
THE END
YOU'LL DIE
meaningless statements that aren't even constructive arguments
you can't see that??
that is the GOP way
MUSHROOM CLOUDS
BOMBS
TERRORISTS
SOCIALISM
YELLOW CAKE
URANIUM
YOU'LL DIE
RUN
it is very entertaining but as all the scare over Iran has proven they lied
they lie once they lie again
their formula for success is scare tactics, guns, god, jesus, morals, family values, abortion
all while getting caught in lie after lie
it is getting old
I am sorry to say anyone that cannot see through it is a sucker.
It's 2009, as a people I would've hoped we were more intelligent than to just fall for sound bite after soundbite.
You're the voice that's getting old--VERY old. Same old, same old rhetoric from wacko left wingers.
If government is sincerley concerned with healthcare costs and not just using it as another lame excuse for the expansion of federal government in general, why hasn't it done something about obesity already?
I may be wrong about this, and if so I would welcome clarification by somebody knowledgeable on the subject and NOT in the employment of a company using it in their products, to correct me. I have read articles about the use of High-Fructose Corn Syrup in our beverages and foods. From what I gathered from these articles it is a factor in weight gain among consumers of these products which is practically all of us.
If there is a body of evidence to demonstrate the potentially harmful effects of this substance on the citizens of this country why is it allowed to be in our diets at all? Why hasn't this substance been banned by the federal government if it is indeed a contributory factor to our nation's health issues? If governement is going to establish itself as the best way to solving big problems shouldn't it already be dealing with lesser ones?
Why is a product allowed to say it contains 0% trans fat when in fact it contains less than some specific amount but not really absolutley NONE? I know I'm old and not up on the latest math principles but when did "0%" mean more than nothing at all? When you add this food with "zero" trans fats to that food with "zero" trans fats in your diet you have a result greater than zero, right? Yet, this deceptive practice is okay according to government.
Why isn't alchohol on the controlled substance list as well as tobacco? Does anyone think these substances are safe and healthy? The government allows these substances because they make huge tax revenues from them. Any health concerns there may be with alcohol or tobacco pale in the face of all the taxes they earn. And now we're supposed to buy into a federal health plan that "won't affect your choices"? Sounds like a campaign promise to me. In my forty years as a registered voter they rarely, if ever, are upheld.
I agree with Elle inasmuch as her comment that president Obama's "plan" needs to be stalled. I'd go further than that though. It needs to be fully developed with "all the cards on the table" and then brought up for debate and finally a public referendum needs to be held before it would have a chance of going into law. A truly concientious and involved public PARTICIPATES in government and helps it stay honest. This government is no different.
Oh, one more thing I would add to the public referendum. In order to participate in the voting you must bring proof of your citizenship. Yes, that is discrimination of a sort, insisting you are a citizen before you may have anything to say about a country's future. Maybe we should even require voters on this issue to be gainfully employed as well. After all, this plan's financial support will most certainly fall onto the shoulders of the American taxpaying public as all the other great schemes coming from Washington have.
I had the unmistakable feeling that the questions were carefully selected by president Obama's team and he fully knew each and every one of them before anyone showed up. Was Charles Gibson supposed to be the voice of oppostion, asking the president the "tough" questions? Sorry, I didn't get the impression that anyone there, including Mr. Gibson, gave the president any real argument at all. I have no problem with a civil discussion but most people get emotional when discussing something they are seriously concerned about and that element seemed to be oddly missing. Compared to the way other networks may have handled the same thing I suppose it wasn't any worse than I have come to expect from TV news in general.
Stop being a one sided cheerleader"jourlalist" network...Your bias is so loud we cant hear a word you are saying
no I will not give it a rest
know why?
because idiots in this country are still republican
they tout palin and newt as saviors
same ol same ol over and over
how could you be such a sucker?
look, after 2000-2008 repubs are done
as a people, THE PEOPLE, who are supposed to care for their nation, we now have to put the dems on notice
get it together or face unemployment as well
this constant shifting from right to left to right has to stop
we have to be smarter
and stop referring to yourselves as right or left
be independant, if you have a brain you cannot be right wing anymore
THEY SCREWED US
why would you let them do it to you again??
"ohh I'm repub I vote my moral conscious"
fool, that is what they count on
your short term memory and your suckerism
let me tell you about your demigod repubs
they do not care about god or jesus, or your guns,the military, or freakin abortion, THEY USE THOSE TO GET YOUR VOTES
GET IT??
Obama got in as a message to all polticians
GET IT TOGETHER, DROP THE BS AND DO WHAT IS RIGHT
I heard an idiot woman on cspan this morning say she liked Palin "cuz she's a christian"
moron
instant stupid vote, just add water
I know protesting and rioting dosn`t work.
It make someone who is walking by who is a sympathizer get into a seat of power and change the laws.
~Peace Glenna~
Subject change.
1.Why is it when the minimum wage is increased the price of everything goes up?
2.Why are corporations allowed to raise the price when the minimum wage goes up and prevent consumers from consumeing putting them right back in the same sinking boat they were in before the minimum wage increase?
~Peace Glenna~
Draw a circle divide it in half.
Write "we the people" on one side and government on the other.
Draw another circle and divide it in 3rds.
Write "we the people" in one section,"corporations" in the other and "government" in the other.
Ask yourself if you are a politition,a chairperson of a corporation,or a consumer(we the people)?
There is no humanbeing in congress the whitehouse, pentegon or anyother Federal building that knows when you go for a blood test,only your doctor knows,think they care/No one is there to care.
If they are what is their rank called,head of health care?
Well there is no "position"(job) like this at the White house.
This could cause a runaway train we may never be able to stop until many are lost/dead.
~Peace Glenna~
George Washington and John Adams.
Then Thomas Jefferson, Democrat-Republican.
James Madison also Democrat-Republican.
James Monroe Democrat-Republican.
John Quincy Adams Democrat-Republican.
Then Andrew Jackson Democrat.
Martin Van Buren Democrat.
Then William Henry Harrison, Whig.
John Tyler, Whig.
James Knox Polk, Democrat.
Zachary Taylor,Whig.
Millard Fillmore,Whig.
Franklin Pierce,Democrat.
James Buchanen,Democrat.
Abraham Lincoln,Republican.
Andrew Johnson,Republican.
Ulysess S.Grant,Republican.
Ruthford B.Hayes,Republican.
James Abrm Garfield,Republican.
Chester Alan arther,Republican.
Grover Clevland,Democrat.
Benjimin Harrison,Republian.
William McKinnly,Republican.
Theadore Rossevelt,Republican.
William Howard Taft,Republican.
(Thomas)Woodrow Wilson,Democrat.
Warren Gamaiel Harding Republican.
Calvin Coolidge,Republican.
Herbert Clarck Hoover,Republican.
Franklin Deleno Roosevelt,Democrat.
Harry S.Truman,Democrat.
Dwite David Eisenhower,Republican.
John Fitzgerald Kennedy,Democrat.
Lyndon B.Johnson,Democrat.
Richard Milhous Nixon.Republican.
Gereald Rudolf Ford,Republican.
James Earl Carter,Democrat.
Ronald Wilson Regan,Republican.
George Bush,Rebublican.
William Clinton,Democrat.
William Clinton,Democrat.
George Bush Jr.Republican.
Barack Hussain Obama,Democrat.
So who Established the (Federal Government),to have other Partys Govern.
Like Whigs and Democrats and Republicans?
If you answered George Washington and John Adams you have answered correctlly upon who rules you from their graves.lol~Peace Glenna~
FYI, the US Federal Gov't was established by the US Constitution.
And what whas it written on?
Hemp,not crack.
And I don`t smoke crack,I crack.
I crack jokes sometimes,when my heart isn`t in the mood to care about you and the rest of the Americans.
~Peace Glenna~
And the next time anyone on the planet accuses me of any kind of drug or alcohol,please be standing by with a urine test or blood test and any standbyers may bet the farm I will come up clean as a whistle.O.K. Shadow.
~Peace Glenna~
The short version -- be nice and be respectful of other's opinions, even if they don't agree with yours, or your comment may be deleted.
Leave a comment
| « What do you report, when you are asked not to report? | After The Big DTV Switch » |