Food Stamp Fraud
I was shopping at the grocery store today, when a guy in the checkout lane next to me proudly pointed to several 12 packs of soda he bought. He told me the cans were going "directly into the machine."
At first I thought he was talking about the soda machine - maybe he was some kind of soda vending machine entrepreneur. It turns out he was talking about the recycling machine.
At a time when our government is spending much more than it is taking in, I think it is time to tighten the restrictions on food stamps, and the guy I met today is a prime example of why.
I don't know why he decided to tell me about his scheme, maybe he thinks it's impressive.
As I bagged my own groceries, he went into more detail about how he needs some cash, so he bought 30 dollars worth of soda with government food stamps. He had no plans to actually drink the soda. He told me he was taking all of the cans to the recycling machine at the store. There, he would put the cans into the machine that gives you a return for your deposit. This would net him about six dollars in cash.
I responded saying "that doesn't seem like a good use of your food stamps." "I know", he said, "but I need the cash."
I understand that with any program designed to help people in need, there is potential for fraud or abuse. But let's think about food stamps for a minute. Should you really be able to buy soda with food stamps? You can't put a monetary worth on the nutritional value of soda because there is none. It's basically corn sweetener and carbonated water.
I've seen this misguided use of foodstamps before. When I started my career, my annual t.v. salary was below the poverty level, so I worked nights and weekends in a grocery store to make ends meet. I saw countless people come through my checkout line, buying expensive steaks, seafood, soda and junk food ... and they paid for it with foodstamps. It always seemed like a gross misuse of the taxpayers' money, and quite frankly it was irritating.
Foodstamps are well intentioned. In a country as richly blessed as ours, nobody should go hungry. If we can afford to waste as much food as we do, we can afford to feed the hungry. But more restrictions are needed on what you can buy with foodstamps.
I think a much better example of federal money going to truly nourish people in need, is the Women Infants and Children (or WIC) program. People who get WIC subsidies can only buy specific foods that meet a nutritional criteria, so recipients aren't blowing their monthly allotment on a week's worth of groceries.
I don't want to see the guy I met today loose his opportunity to shop with his food stamps, but I do want the federal government to stop his ability to game the system and collect pennies on our dollar.
77 comments
There is so much fraud going on that I wouldn't be surprised that fraud has now been legalized. You have to come out from behind the desk and see what goes on. I can't believe that you haven't encountered this before. I am so sick and tired of it but it does no good to complain because everyone is doing it (not me). I wouldn't lower myself.
Enlighten me please what are SNAP
benefits. I just want to make sure it's not something that we're being taxed on.
It's just a name change, so yes, you are being taxed and I hope you and Jeff make over $250.00 a year. That would make my day.
I don't see any harm in having someone (Ted) express their opinion about something they saw first hand. It's wrong and actually - it's fraudulent. Just as those that "cash in" benefits rather then buy the food it was intended for.
Everyone has a "right" to their opinion and should be allowed to express it.
As time went on, we got a notice that only certain cheeses, eggs, etc. could be bought with the stamps.
This guy had to have some money on him, as unless things have changed, taxable items were NOT allowed to be bought with food stamps. If they can now, my oh my how things have changed.
Call me a "hater", but, I think people on Welfare, food stamps etc. should be given vouchers like in the old days. This way, they can only shop at certain stores, and only buy certain food items. We the taxpayers are funding these programs, and I'd like to see my money spent more wisely.
I'm sure the man intended to dump out the soda, as we all know you can't put full soda cans or bottles into those machines.
I am not disputing what you witnessed or your right to feel the way you felt. However, not all recipients are crooks and not everyone even knows that there is a market out there that actually buys SNAP benefits for .50 cents on the dollar. That gentleman sounded like he was very desperate to resort to spend $30.00 to get $6.00. How does a homeless person cook or heat canned or cold food?, which is all they are allowed to purchase. I think the woman who mentioned nutritional education was on the right track. However, nothing in Gov happens quickly and there are actually hungry people out there. How would you feel if you had to buy lunch meat for one sandwhich because any more than that would spoil. Lunch meat is also high in sodium and many of these clients already have diabetes and hypertension. Things just need to change. Jack, maybe I am pissey, but it is very dishearting when you can't help and all you can do is watch. We are not allowed to even given a dollar for bus fair at work but somehow I think I may have just bought the guy a hot meal. Yes, some say "no" because they don't have good intentions but you would be surprised how many individuals actually accept a meal or a warm drink in the morning.
I think a lot of us are essentially saying the same thing; there are ways this program can be improved. By no means do I believe that all (or even a majority) of the recipients are abusing these benefits.
It must be quite frustrating at times to not be able to help more then you do already. But we all must realize this is a tough time for all of us economically and watching some perhaps abuse a benefit is frustrating to say the least.
Since I've been the food shopper for the family for years I believe there are many food items that can be purchased in single portions on a day to day basis. Also looking for canned items that have flip tops might be an option. Most deli's will make a single sandwich if they are asked.
Just as you've made it clear not to judge "all" I think the same would apply in reverse.
Here is a story that happened to my stepson when he worked for Kenny Rogers chicken in the summer when he was going to college.....He came home oneday from work with a whole chicken dinner for us and was VERY confused.....he said there was this person who was outside the restraunt with a sign " NEED HELP TO FEED MY FAMILY OF 5......." the guy was there for a couple of days, people gave him money.......so my stepson thought it would be nice if, when he left he gave the guy a dinner to take home.......so when he pulled up to the guy to give him the bag with all the food the guys says to him " I dont want your damn food....I need the money....." he refused to take the food........in fact he had the balls to ask my stepson for CASH..................
My point is that there is SOOOOO much BS out there........... compassion is good, if it is directed to the RIGHT thing...............
I just love standing behind these people in the grocery line, watching the brand name purchases and ho-ho's, ring dings, soda,ice cream etc go down the belt and then looking at my own carefully chosen store brand purchases thinking..gee I'm paying for their food and they can afford that crap when I am looking to save $...Nice society. I really would love to speak up and tell them to put the garbage back and go pick up nutritious stuff since I'm paying for it, but we can't because these entitlement types really have a huge chip on their shoulders.
Missy if you are so bent over this, start handing out your own hard earned cash.
Sorry Jessica-but you don't need to buy soda for your teens. It's all about choice and the price of soda is ridiculous-you'd find your food stamps would go much further if you chose wisely.
What did my mom do - she used her head and cooked smart.
How much does a pot of soup cost and how many meals can you get out of it?
Same applies to a pan of sauce. A few pounds of macaroni will feed many.
Shopping wisely instead of using expensive prepacked foods will certainly make a big difference in stretching your dollar. But that's where I think the problem lies....it's become a sense of "entitlement" rather then the "benefit" it should be considered.
Jessica-get over the pity party. Lawn Jockey was trying to make a point that soda is a poor choice. And really, in one breath you are complaining that your food stamps don't last you the month and the next you are saying you are buying a treat? Again, it's about choices...buy a big bag of flour, and sugar and some bruised apples and make a nice treat out of that-it will go further than that lousy bottle of soda. Shop wisely, think about it and you can stretch that food dollar.
BTW-I raised 3 kids on my own without the benefit of food stamps-how? I shopped wisely stretched the food budget.
When I was a cop we arrested a lot of people with the food stamp card who also had foxwoods and mohegan sun players club cards. God bless America.
Food stamps should be used for bread, milk, peanut butter, eggs,cheese, and meat, fruits and veggies.
Not only did this woman not have one nutricious item in her cart, but she had tips on her nails, and her hair done with extensions.
It must be nice to have the money to treat yourself to a manicure and hair appointment. I can't do any of these things because they take too much out of my check in taxes, taking care of these abusers. I resent this very much.
I am not begrudging those who really need these food stamps, but please be wise in your choices.
At every shopping trip I make, I have a fistfull of coupons, and never buy brand names.
Something has to be done.
what is the bloody difference??? one abuser is rich and contributes to congressmen and presidents while the other one lives in a homeless shelter??? come on people!!!
Ted, btw, i'm with you...in senator joe McCarty days, i'd be locked up as a "comm-symp" and one of the best parties (food, booze, girls, vice party) was at a Communist owned bar in Salamanca Spain...
If you spend, or should I say the taxpayer spends $158.00 a month on milk, then you need to check your priorities. At $4.00 a gallon, that's enough for 39 gallons of milk a month. How in the h--- do you use 39 gallons a month unless you are using the food stamps and then selling the milk to others for cash? Milk at the convenience store is $2.99. Buy it there and use the food stamps for food. Also, learn how to make more than mac and cheese.
I know your probably having it pretty tough, so buy a large pk. of stew beef and make some stew, this is great weather for it, and it is fairly cheap to make, as are alot of homemade soups. Making a large pot of spaghetti sauce is alot more healthy as well, and pretty cheap. You can always freeze the sauce for another meal or two as well.
My husband is Diabetic, and when he was in the hospital 2 years ago for 3 weeks, he had so many meds. to take, especially Prednizone, that is played havoc with his sugar. They had to wind up giving him insulin shots, as it went so high, but when it went too low, they gave him milk. I asked the nurse why, and she told me, because it has a lot of sugar in it, so it would help raise his sugar when it was too low. I do my research, but that was a new one on me. I use 1% milk, and it has 12 grams of sugar per serving, so you need to go light on milk use as well.
There are a lot of recipe sites on the web for inexpensive meals, so please familiarize yourself with them for the health of your family, and also to help with your financial situation.
Hopefully you didn't take this wrong, as I am only trying to be a little helpful.
I will say that I'm lucky to have my husband's insurance (through a town) cause I saw that if I used my company's insurance, it would cost me $863 a month. If it got to that point, I would either (a) go on welfare; or (b) put my kids on the Husky Plan, cause there's no way in hell . . .
I grew up in a lower middle-class family, and yes, my mom used to buy powdered milk, no soda, cheaper items, etc., to help us get by, so I'm sure that people could be more frugal - that idea about watering down the Propel was a good idea.
I remember our neighbors had to get Welfare for a couple of years due to the dad having a serious operation, but they got vouchers, NO money. The rent was paid to the landlord directly, and the vouchers were for certain stores for food and clothes. You couldn't own a car, or even a phone. If you needed to make a call, you either went to the neighbors, or the corner store to use one.
I don't mind folks who really need assistance, but have seen a few that drive pretty nice cars, have plasma tvs, and a few othe nice goodies.
As far as the Propel, we really like it mixed in with water, as I refuse to drink those juicy fruity things, and we need to stay away from sugary things.
Like you, I don't give to folks begging. We don't see many around here, but years ago there was a fellow in the downtown area that use to. I was stopped for a light one time, he asked if I could spare a 5 dollar bill, and when I said NO, he called me a stuck up B****. Hmmmm, that cured me.
what ass ok'd that?????????
you should be able to buy food, real food, no snacks, candy, cigarettes, booze, ice cream, NONE OF IT
if you are on food stamps you should be in survival mode AND the govt should be making sure that OUR money is spent WISELY
ugg
You can tell the families who are not abusing the systems from the ones who are. I have one mother that comes in every month. She's buying up all the dented cans that are 50 percent off, buying all the neccesarry staples, flour, milk, bread, and all the good wholesome foods. She makes her money stretch as much as she can. Then you have the other family that comes in buying all prepared foods, steaks, ect. Her kid came up with a box of Corn Flakes, and she has the guts to say to the kid, sorry, don't have enough money. Huh? I'd buy my kid two boxes of Corn Flakes before I'd buy a steak. Isn't it supposed to be for the kids?
Wic has it's own flaws too. They shouldn't allow the powerdered versions because drug dealers will buy the formula to cut their cocaine with. I even had one lady come up with a more expensive formula than Wic allows, and she exclaimed that she wouldn't use the cheaper formula because it's for scuzzies. Excuse me then, GET A JOB then!!!!
FIRST OF ALL YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED TO ADMIT THAT YOU ARE A RED SOX FAN. BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY I MENTIONED THAT WE ARE NOT ALLOWED TO GIVE OUT MONEY OR ACCEPTS GIFTS OR WE WILL BE FIRED. SO YES IF I WERE IN A DIFFERENT FIELD I WOULD HELP PEOPLE WITH MY OWN CASH BECAUSE THAT'S THE WAY I WAS RAISED. NOONE, CERTAINLY NOT ME ASKED YOU TO GIVE ANYONE CASH OUT OF YOUR POCKET STUPID. NOONE CARES WHAT YOU DO WITH YOUR DISPOSABLE INCOME KEEP IT! FEEL GOOD ABOUT YOURSELF AND SLEEP WELL. I WANT EVERYONE TO HAVE THEIR NEEDS MET. SO LOSER, TAKE CARE OF YOU AND YOUR OWN THAT'S FINE BUT DON'T KNOCK SOMEONE ELSE WHO WANTS TO HELP. WHY DOES MY DESIRE TO HELP SOMEONE BOTHER YOU? I AM A SINGLE PARENT AND GIVE WHAT I CAN-THAT'S MY BUSINESS,MIND YOUR OWN.
GIVE THEM A JOB!!!OFFER!!
WHAT A JOKE THIS IS, YOU SEEM TO ONLY CARE ABOUT THE PROBLEM NOT THE SOLUTION.
PEOPLE MANAGE TO ABUSE PROGRAMS AND CHEAT EVERYWHERE FROM FOOD STAMPS TO INSIDER TRADING, OFFICIALS ACCEPTING HOME REPAIRS AND BRIBES FOR POLITICAL FAVORS. WHERE ARE ALL OF YOU WHEN IT'S TIME TO FORM SOLUTIONS, FOCUS GROUPS OR ANY VIABLE REMEDIES. I WISH I COULD GET A BAILOUT ON MY BILLS.
I think the restrictions on what you can buy with food stamps are good ideas but I doubt they'd be enforced any more than the use of cell phones while driving is.
And, as many have pointed out, what the poor really need is some instruction on how to spend wisely. It's not so much a sense of entitlement as it is that they think EVERYONE has a cell phone and cable and HBO and internet. I know plenty of well-off people don't have one or more of those things because they know they're not worth the money.
But start at the top and get the big wasters first.
Get of your high horse. Don't tell me I'm not part of the solution. I'd rather help out the working poor who cannot get the help they need because they are working. These are the one's who can't get food stamp assistance because they work and are trying to make life better for themselves. 4 years ago, I started packing up food items for Thanksgiving to give to a neighborhood family in need. This single mother who worked two jobs to put a roof over her families head and food on the table couldn't get no type of assistance because, she made 100 dollars too much a month to recieve any type of help. Her husband was killed by a drunk driver with no insurance. Since that first year, other neighbors heard what I have done and offered their help. This year we are feeding 6 families in our neighborhood that need our help. People on food stamps can go and buy a turkey with their stamps. Hard working people like the ones we help actually have bills they need to pay, like heating bills that food stamp people can get help with.
I have no problems helping people who are willing to try and help themselves. But if you look at the total amount of abuse that is going on with the welfare system, I'm sure it would far exceed the 7 billion bailout.
And why is it that there are some food stamp assistance people out there that can afford to buy drugs? Make a drug test requirement part of the paperwork. If they can afford to buy drugs, they don't need my tax money.
The other sickening one is John Rowland who is running for mayor of Waterbury apparently. Those people are dang fools if they elect this man. And I agree one of his problems was letting the kooks in the nursing homes. My mentally-retarded sister was in there, and I had to get her out of there cause there was a drug addict who was wrongly placed there who was trying to take advantage of her.
THE WORKING POOR DO GET FOOD STAMPS THOSE ARE THE PEOPLE I AM CONCERNED ABOUT DIPSTICK. I CAN'T EVEN AFFORD A HIGH HORSE- BUT I BET YOU COULD. JUST BECAUSE A PERSON RECEIVES SNAP BENEFITS DOES NOT MEAN IT'S ILLEGAL TO HAVE A COMPUTER. I'M NOT SURPRISED YOU HELP PEOPLE ON THANKSGIVING BECAUSE OF COURSE THE OTHER 364 DAYS OF THE YEAR THESE PEOPLE HAVE WONDERFUL MEALS. TRY SERVING FOOD AT SOUP KITCHEN ALL YEAR.
Chick gets knocked up- father of the kid goes to jail. I pay to prosecute the father, then I pay to incarcerate him. Then I pay for the babies momma free rent. And her food stamps. And her welfare. Then I'm asked to give to the food bank so she could blow her welfare money at the club and the new lil' wayne cd. I have to clothe her kids. I have to pay her kids the teachers salary because you know damn well she isn't paying any taxes.
In the interest of full disclosure,
I have a family member collecting entitlements. Had it good, well educated, good job, but wanted to be a party animal and went off the deep end. Loser.
Its time to give America back to the people who work every day. And we can start by putting Obama rubber stamp Rosa Delauro out to pasture in a few years.
And by the way Ted- thanks for the post. It took guts. Best thing to do though is for you to not go back and forth with people on here, in all honesty it isn't worth it for a man in your position.
please tell me Rowland is not running for office
I thought convicted felons were banned
Besides whether the money is spent on oranges or orange soda, its just as spent. Get over it.
Whether it's for food or housing ... there are (and should be) rules and restrictions. I don't mind helping those who REALLY need help ... but I don't want my tax dollars given to some sterno bum, so he can buy another bottle of Thunderbird.
Have you ever taken the governments money or a check and spent it on anything not nutritious,your as guilty as the fella with the cans.
Ever wonder why the poor have diabeties,something wrong with steak?for the poor!
I think if you were so poor that you had to be on food stamps you may like a soda once and awhile,why be punished for being on food stamps,and I am on food stamps and I will make sure to buy a case of soda next time I go you made me thirsty thinking I will be deprived.
In desperate times people do desperate things.
If you needed medicine to save your Mothers life and it took 6 dollars and you have the oppourtunity,would you?Don`t guilt trip folk who were caught in the wheel of poverty.
You may want to walk a mile in his shoes,think you could?
I think you would do better with a sign on wall street and march there.
Don`t blame food stamp recipitants for your Governments failiers of unemployment.
Poor food stamp recipitant should not be deprived any craving of food or soda they want,you sound like a meanie Ted,or grouch from sesame street,go cookie monster for a month.
Guess what, you can eat a cookie and drink a soda and it wont kill you I have done it before,it is safe,excess in anything will kill you!
~Peace Glenna~
What I do think is wrong is that the single mother with 5 children to different fathers refuses to get off her ass and work so she doesnt have to be on welfare! Guarenteed this person send her kids to daycare for $20 a month or some ridiculous amount, while she sits at home or goes shopping. I have seen it, I know people who do it. Meanwhile, my husband and I (who have been married for 5 yrs) all of sudden need some financial help (which we only stayed on for 2 months) and get ridiculed because of the welare abusers. We did things right and hit a bad time financially. IT happens.
Harassed you say,yeah I just had a redetirmination,sent everything in to meet my criteria,was accepted and today I recive a letter and if I don`t have it all in by the 7th which is a saturday,I am cancled.
My current bills arn`t even here yet.
I have no car to take them to the post office to get a head start.
Funny how before my accident while all you all were sleeping I helped build this society to have it eff me in the end,so I said to God I am not praying for your children anymore,by tonight I am shure I will change my mind.~Peace Glenna~
And WIC isn’t so great either, people try and buy Jalapeño cheese. I always want ask: "Are your kids going to eat that??" Isn’t that what this program is really for!!
I watched a case worker take something from my table and put it in her pocket.
So to see if she was a lier too I said did you just take blank off the table and put it in your pocket,she said no,I said I just saw you,she said oh and laughed,I didn`t think it was funny,so I fired her and called her supervisor.
She belongs with Madoff,so do I for stealing my own rites from myself.
You know what our rites are if we catch someone stealing in our home,now don`t you.
~Peace Glenna~p.s. It may have been a pack of cinnamin gum,but I was looking at the principal of the whole thing.
market, barley, lentils. bagged beans, chicken, beef. fish, chops, mineral water, tea. I am certain that that grocery list would anger those who think I should have nothing but gruel. Damned if you buy crap, damned if you boy upscale food with the food stamps.
The short version -- be nice and be respectful of other's opinions, even if they don't agree with yours, or your comment may be deleted.
Leave a comment
| « Where on "Ugly Betty" is Sonia Baghdady? | DWTS: Sprinting Away From The Dance Floor » |