Opinion In the News
My mother-in-law came to stay with my family for several days. (Now, before anybody posts any sympathy responses, let me go on the record as saying that I truly do enjoy spending time with her.)
Among the many interesting things we talked about, was a television news anchor in her hometown market, who has started doing a nightly commentary during the station's late newscast. She told me that sometimes, that commentary includes his own personal opinion.
The anchor has been in the market for decades, is respected, and has proven himself as a solid journalist. In fact, my mother-in-law has been a big fan of his for a long time. But I have to admit, I was taken aback when she told me that he has started a nightly commentary.
There's no question, we're seeing more overtly opinionated news on some of the cable networks. Personally, I do not want to see that trend spill over into local news. How do you feel? Would you trust a local television station that featured an anchor discussing his or her opinions? What does that do to your impression of them striving to be fair and impartial?
As anchors, it is our job to be as informed as possible about the news we deliver. Beyond that... it's my opinion that your opinion is much more important than mine.
12 comments
Displaying emotion while reporting on a tragic occurance or shock when reporting on a horrific crime is certainly acceptable and I would think expected of you and your peers.
What is not tolerable is when a reporter weighs in with conjecture or displays obvious personal bias during segments on politics, religion, or other issues which bring an element of contention to the table.
Reporters have a right to state their opinion of course, just as every other citizen, but it would behoove them to keep their day job clean of such and instead use totally separate forum for the purpose. A blog for instance...
Now, if there was another opportunity for this reporter/anchor to host a show (even on his own network) where opinions were an integral part of the show, then fine, I'm sure he could wear both hats effectively.
A journalist's opinion is one that should be left off camera in this case. If for an example, (NOTE: JUST AN EXAMPLE) you don't like Pres. Bush and 45% of your market supports Pres. Bush and you go ON CAMERA and comment on the President in your PERSONAL OPINION numerous times. You will loose 45% of your market, which may close a station.
Bob Brown
Orange
you're right about "determined coverable and non coverable has more to do with personal feelings of a station mgr/editir than time, money or public interest"
except you left out OWNER
Years ago I trained for TV Radio, I was turned off by the fact that it is so CONTROLLED, even the songs on the radio, I mean why do you think you hear American Band on PLR seven times a freakin day??
people running the place have no imagination and are control freaks
you are however wrong about the Iraq War, what is in the news is just the tip of the iceberg
we left Afghanistan to invade on the whim of GW and Cheney
it is in the shape it is now because these guys suck at managing and planning
you have to ask some serious questions
why did GW want a reason to invade Iraq since 2000?
why did he try to blame 9/11 on Iraq and invade Iraq first instead of going after who really attacked us???
Bin laden was in Afghanistan, that comes first
then when that is completely taken care of THEN we take on the next SOB
our problem was and is Iran, they supported the Taliban and Bin with counterfeit US money they have been making since WE sold the Shah OUR printing machines before Khomeini took over Iran
Why do we not deal with Iran??
Answer:
BECAUSE HALLIBURTON IS HEAVILY INVESTED IN IRAN, HAS SEVERAL COMPANIES THERE EVEN THOUGH IT IS ILLEGAL FOR A US CITIZEN {CHENEY} TO DO BUSINESS IN IRAN, IN FACT ..HALLIBURTON EVEN HAS THE PENSIONS OF THE NYPD & NYFD INVESTED IN FREAKIN IRAN
SO DON'T GO SAYING THAT NEWS IS NEGATIVE ABOUT IRAN
THEY {REPORTERS} HAVE DONE A TERRIBLE DISSERVICE TO THIS COUNTRY AND HER CITIZENS IN COVERING THE CRAPOLA THAT THE BUSH REGIME HAS BEEN UP TO
LESSON OVER
It is ones thing to do it. It is another to recognize this and try to correct it, which 8 as made no attempts to do. You STILL have that New England weather map on your station. Why do you need it? You are in New Haven, not Hartford, Sprignfield,MA, Boston or Providence, RI.
turn into an "opinion" hour. Unfortunately that does seem to be the trend. Look atGood Morning America... goldilocks Diane Sawyer lets you know her opinion, with her squinting eyes and antagonizing questions. We need honest reporting and stories about what's happening right in our neighborhoods.
The short version -- be nice and be respectful of other's opinions, even if they don't agree with yours, or your comment may be deleted.
Leave a comment
| « Do Sudden Weather Changes Make You Sick? | Different Rules for the Cops? » |